How Much Would It Cost
A lot, but be wary of any politician brandishing a precise number. Medicare for all would be a very big change to many parts of the health system and the government, and it would involve a lot of tough policy decisions. That makes calculating a price tricky.
Economists have produced various estimates. Its probably most helpful to think about the range. Give or take, they said the Medicare for all system would cost around the same as the current system government, employer and individual spending combined. But even the most conservative spending estimate would involve a huge shift of health care dollars from individuals and businesses to the federal government. Medicare for all would be an enormous expansion of government spending, and would almost certainly require large tax increases.
Mr. Sanders recently released a fact sheet with some ideas about how he might finance the system. His proposal is centered on a large payroll tax that would be paid by medium and large companies and by families earning more than $29,000 a year. But it also would include higher taxes on corporations and people with high incomes. Altogether, his proposed taxes would raise far less money than most estimates of what the program would cost.
But I Work Hard Why Should I Care About Snap And Wic
Funding programs like SNAP and WIC is a moral issue. How a nation treats its less fortunate citizens says a lot about a country. Should a great nation like America only worry about the bottom line? Is our nation so consumed with money that we cannot stop to help those in need? The poor should not be neglected or exploited.
What Is The Overall Plan
One of the biggest misconceptions about Medicare for All is that theres just one proposal on the table.
In fact, there are a number of different proposals out there, explained Katie Keith, JD, MPH, a research faculty member for Georgetown Universitys Center on Health Insurance Reforms.
Most people tend to think of the most far-reaching Medicare for All proposals, which are outlined in bills sponsored by Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Pramila Jayapal. But there are a number of proposals out there that would expand the role of public programs in healthcare, she said.
Although all of these plans tend to get grouped together, there are key differences among the various options, Keith added, and, as we know in healthcare, the differences and details really matter.
According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, Sanders and Jayapals bills share many similarities, such as:
- comprehensive benefits
Journal of General Internal MedicineTrusted Source . The objective is for a single publicly funded health system, like that in Canada, the United Kingdom, and Australia.
Right now in the United States, multiple groups pay for healthcare. That includes private health insurance companies, employers, and the government, through programs like Medicare and Medicaid.
The system we have right now places Americas health system on an island on its own, away from its peers on the global stage.
The current Medicare program wouldnt exactly vanish.
Don’t Miss: Is Fidelis Medicaid Or Medicare
Can Bernie Sanders Medicare For All Work No Time Soon Princeton Professor Says At Penn
The cost of Medicare for All could turn the government into “a health insurance company with armed forces,” Princeton economist Paul Starr said Friday at a health care cost event by University of Pennsylvania’s Leonard Davis Institute.
Medicare for All is one of the most talked-about policy proposals of the 2020 Democratic primary but could it ever happen?
According to Paul Starr, a Pulitzer Prize-winning health sociologist who worked on the failed Bill Clinton health-care plan in the 1990s, the answer is: not any time soon. For one thing, extending the program for older and disabled Americans to everyone would consume so much of the federal governments resources, it would require massive tax increases and turn the government into a health insurance company with armed forces, Starr said Friday at a health care cost conference held by the University of Pennsylvanias Leonard Davis Institute.
Whats more, he noted, putting everyone on government health care would completely dismantle the highly profitable insurance industry while lowering payments to the medical industry both of which hold huge political sway.
During the most recent Democratic debate, Sanders pointed to a study in the medical journal Lancet that found a Medicare for All plan like his could save billions of dollars a year.
Who Is Bernie Sanders
Bernie Sanders was born in Brooklyn, New York, and was educated at the University of Chicago, which early on influenced his strong beliefs about combatting equality within the US. Bernie Sanders moved to Vermont in 1968, where he became Mayor of Burlington in 1981. He was subsequently reelected three times.
In 1990, Bernie Sanders was elected to the House of Representatives from Vermonts at-large district. It was there he served for 16 years before being elected to the Senate in 2006, 2012, and again in 2018 .
In 2015, Bernie Sanders announced his intention to run for president, and despite losing to Hillary Clinton in the Democratic Primaries, he managed to win 23 primaries and garnered 43% of the pledged delegates.
In February of 2019, he announced he would try a second time to become a candidate for election to be president, and with his rabid army of supporters, he is very much a favored candidate.
In April of 2019, Bernie Sanders announced his plan to transition healthcare in the US to a single-payer healthcare system, one where a single government-run plan provides insurance coverage to all Americans.
This plan is called the Medicare for All Act, and is a key hallmark of his presidency.
You May Like: Does Cigna Have A Medicare Supplement Plan
College For All And Cancel Student Debt
It will cost $2.2 trillion to make public colleges, universities and trade schools tuition-free and to cancel all student debt over the next decade. It is fully paid for by a modest tax on Wall Street speculation that will raise an estimated $2.4 trillion over ten years. Click here to read the plan.
Is This Plan Popular
Its pretty popular with a big caveat. In recent surveys, just over half of Americans consistently say they approve of the idea. Medicare for all polls even better among Democratic voters, the people who are participating in presidential primaries and caucuses.
But support has proved malleable. Public opinion surveys also show that many voters who say they like Medicare for all dont know much about the details, and some change their minds after learning about certain features, like the loss of private insurance or possible tax increases. In a general election, voters are likely to hear far more about these counterarguments than they are now.
Democratic health proposals that would allow people to choose a government plan or keep their current insurance arrangements are also quite popular.
Recommended Reading: Will Medicare Pay For Breast Augmentation
Would Sanderss Health Plan Lower American Health Spending Its Hard To Tell
One of Sanderss main arguments in favor of his health care bill is that American health spending is out of control and single-payer would rein it in.
There is broad consensus from conservative to progressive economists that the Senate Medicare for All bill, as written, would result in substantial savings to the American people, a paper released by his office argues.
There are certainly policies in the Sanders plan that would reduce American health care spending. For one, moving all Americans on to one health plan would reduce the administrative waste in our health care system in the long run.
American doctors spend lots of money dealing with insurers because there are thousands of them, each negotiating their own rate with every hospital and doctor. An appendectomy, for example, can cost anywhere from $1,529 to $186,955, depending on how good of a deal an insurer can get from a hospital.
That doesnt happen in a single-payer system like the one Sanders proposes. Instead of dealing with dozens of insurers that set hundreds of prices, doctors only need to send bills to the federal government.
One 2003 article in the New England Journal of Medicineestimates that the United States spends twice as much on administrative costs as Canada. A 2011 study in the journal Health Affairs estimates American doctors spend four times as much dealing with insurance companies compared with Canada.
What Is The Sanders Bill
The Sanders bill includes an exceptionally generous benefit package. Sanderss single-payer proposal would create a universal Medicare program that covers all American residents in one government-run health plan. It would bar employers from offering separate plans that compete with this new, government-run option.
Also Check: Is Imvexxy Covered By Medicare
Will You Be Able To Keep Your Doctor
This is a sticking point for many people and why not? It can take time to find a doctor you trust, and once you do, you dont want to walk away from that relationship.
The good news is that the Medicare for All bills generally build on the current provider system, so doctors and hospitals that already accept Medicare could likely continue to do so, Keith said.
What isnt clear yet is whether all providers would choose to participate in the program since they currently wont be required to do so.
The bills include a private pay option where providers and individuals could come up with their own arrangement to pay for healthcare, but this would be outside of the Medicare for All program, and they would have to follow certain requirements before doing so, explained Keith.
The Basics Of Medicare For All
What to know about Bernie Sanderss health care plan.
Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.
Give this article
Its possible youve tuned out when the Democrats running for president have tussled over Medicare for all. But now that Bernie Sanders, who introduced the Medicare for All Act in the Senate, is ascending in the nominating contest, its a good time to take a closer look at what it would mean for the health system, your health insurance and finances, and the federal budget.
Heres our quick primer, with some suggestions for further reading.
Don’t Miss: How Do You File For Medicare
Will Preexisting Conditions Be Covered
Yes. Under the Affordable Care Act, a health insurer cant refuse to give you coverage because of a health issue you already have. That includes cancer, diabetes, asthma, and even high blood pressure.
Before the ACA, private insurers were allowed to turn down prospective members, charge higher premiums, or limit benefits based on your health history.
Medicare for All plans will operate in the same way as the ACA.
What Would This Mean For Doctors Hospitals And Drug Companies
Under Medicare for all, doctors and hospitals would remain in private hands. But because the government insurance would effectively be their only source of income, the government would have much more control over the medical system. Nearly every estimate of the cost of Medicare for all assumes that the public system would pay doctors and hospitals less than they currently earn from private insurers. That could mean substantial pay cuts for certain health care providers who see a lot of privately insured patients.
Drug companies would probably take the biggest cut. Estimates tend to assume that the government would pay them substantially lower prices for their products than they currently receive.
Don’t Miss: Does Medicare Cover Ent Specialist
Other Modifications To Medicare For All Could Make The Economic Benefits Much Larger Boosting The Economy By As Much As 12 Percent In 2060
We also scored some versions of Medicare for All that are less generous. For example, when analyzing a version of Medicare for All that: does not expand benefits to include long-term care or dental services, and is financed with premiums, we find that the economy would be 12 percent larger in 2060.
*One notable caveat to the above analysis is that the overall size of the economy is not a perfect measure of overall economic welfare. Its possible that most people would be better off under Medicare for All even with a smaller economy. Well release an analysis exploring these welfare effects sometime in February 2020.
Kody Carmody of the Penn Wharton Budget Model
What Other Costs Are Cut With Medicare For All
We will no longer be paying for CEO bonuses or stock options, fancy corporate offices, club memberships, corporate jets, annual retreats, board member compensation, commercials or advertising, drug reps, or the vacations and perks they use to bribe doctors and hospital administrators.
A simple single-payer system would address the huge amount of money wasted on billing and administrative expenses. There would be a set fee schedule, one billing network, and no haggling or pleading to see if a procedure is covered. Plus, debt collection costs would be eliminated.
Some people would lose their jobs debt collectors and insurance salespeople for instance. And the health actuaries and medical underwriters getting paid lots of money to figure out how to deny policies and coverage would be sent an official letter ending their contract.
Don’t Miss: Am I Qualified For Medicare
In The Long Run Medicare For All Would Improve Health In The United States
Under Medicare for All, the uninsured rate by design falls to zero. And because there are no copayments, in our model, no one chooses to forgo medical treatment. By 2060, we project that this increased coverage would reduce the share of the population that is seriously ill from 15 percent to 13 percent, increasing life expectancy by about 2 years and growing the U.S. population by 3 percent.
Read Also: Does Medicare Pay For Varicose Veins
Change The Healthcare System As We Know It
Several thorny issues emerge in the Medicare for All debate, ranging from doctor pay to prescription drug development.
Sanders’ plan assumes doctors and hospitals would be paid by the government at a rate equal to current Medicare reimbursement rates, which are generally lower than the rate private insurers pay.
This would save the system money overall, but would also significantly cut reimbursement rates for some healthcare providers. Critics of the plan argue that cutting those reimbursement rates to the Medicare level, which are 40% lower than private plans in some cases, couldn’t work because it would disincentivize people from becoming doctors and roil the healthcare system as we know it.
Advocates note the plan would also eliminate a slew of overhead and administrative costs by streamlining the billing and reporting system. Instead of dealing with a confusing jumble of private insurers and plans, doctors and healthcare providers would only work with a single payer.
In addition, Sanders’ plan would attempt to extract lower prices from pharmaceutical manufacturers. But critics contend that lower payments will reduce spending on research and development at pharma companies and may stifle innovation in the field.
Recommended Reading: How To Apply For Medicare Through Social Security
This Is Your Movement
Bernie is counting on all of us to continue fighting for our progressive agenda. There is only one way we will transform this country and that is together.
Add your name to tell Bernie you’re in.
By providing my phone number, I consent to receive periodic text message alerts from Bernie Sanders and his affiliated campaigns, including Friends of Bernie Sanders. Friends of Bernie Sanders will never charge for these updates, but carrier message & data rates may apply. Text STOP to 67760 to stop receiving messages. Text HELP to 67760 for more information.Terms & Conditions
What Are The Other Democratic Candidates Proposing
With the exception of Elizabeth Warren, who also endorses a Medicare for all plan, the other top remaining Democratic presidential candidates have all backed flavors of a public option health plan, in which people can choose between buying a government plan or buying private health insurance. These various public-option plans would expand the reach of government insurance and improve the generosity of government subsidies to help middle-income people pay for insurance. They would also probably affect insurance markets, causing some people to lose their current coverage even if they did not choose the public plan.
But public option approaches would preserve more of the current structure of our health system, with its varying plans, premiums, deductibles and co-payments. These approaches would also require increases in federal spending, but the increases would be smaller because people, businesses and state governments would largely continue paying for health care in the manner they do now.
Obamacare Didnt Fix Costs Coverage
Most important, Medicare for All would cover everyone. Obamacare has certainly benefited millions of people. But it has left 30 million people still uninsured,and by continuing to rely on the private insurance industry, it has not contained costs or controlled the inflation of costs.
Bernies plan is not some wild, disruptive idea. Medicare has been in effect for senior citizens for a half-century, and it is the most popular part of our system. Many 64-year-olds can hardly wait to be 65 so they are eligible. Bernies plan would simply extend Medicare to all age groups. Moreover, Medicare for All would not be a government-run system or socialized medicine, as opponents often argue. It is merely government-financed. The delivery of care by providers would remain private, as it is now for senior citizens. Patients would have free choice of providers, without being confined to networks by insurance companies, and they would not lose their insurance because of job loss.
Recommended Reading: Can You Have Kaiser And Medicare